I'm about to head to the gym but thought I would try to articulate something to myself before I go.
Having now finished The Scarlet Letter, attending especially to the language of theatre (scenes, roles, parts, actors, spectators, character), I can see if I'm anywhere closer to a diss topic/argument.
I paid close attention to the relationship between inside and outside (outward manifestations of inner states; or, outward disguises/facades that hide/cover the "true" inner state. is the outward, finally, all that is knowable? all that is true? remember that the moral that hawthorne provides [while simultaneously claiming it is only one of "many morals" to be discovered in the book] is to "Be true! Be true! Be true!" Is it possible to "be true"? What does it mean to be true? Be true to what? Inner character? Innate wickedness?)
There is also a great deal of the language of "mingling." Often, mingling/mixing/adulterating is "bad." better to be pure, separate, isolated, autonomous, independent.
The custom-house introductory piece argues for the greatness of the independent man/human. Dependence is seen as weakness. Self-reliance is the goal and aim. The Scarlet Letter is finally a tragedy because Hester--the outcast, the pariah--finally returns to Boston to again take on the shame of the scarlet letter for the rest of her days. She is dependent on it somehow for her identity (like the wife in "the birth-mark").
Throughout all of Hawthorne runs a current of "matrimonial fear" (a phrase, I believe, from Young Goodman Brown!). I believe this matrimonial fear has to do with the dangers of mingling, of losing oneself, one's independence, one's hermetic self-hood by being caught-up in the life of another. The scarlet letter has only one independent character--Pearl--and she is the only one who at the end is rewarded with an inheritance and a home away from Boston. Possibly she is married, but that is never made clear.
Hester depends on her letter, her shame. Dimmesdale depends on his own letter, and his shame. When the truth is outed at the end he dies. Without his secret shame, he is not himself. Likewise, Chillingworth depends on Dimmesdale for his selfhood. He focuses all his energies on Dimmesdale and without him perishes.
The question is: what has the language of theatre (what I want to call the rhetoric of theatricality) to do with this fear of dependence/mingling/matrimony?
Another piece of this is the language of race (blackness/whiteness) and slavery (bondage) throughout Hawthorne's work. Iron chains, ties that bind, lack of free will. Hester is a "slave" to her letter.
master/slave
husband/wife
are these related? the slave has no autonomy, is "dependent" in a fucked up way. the master is also dependent (Hegel, master/slave dialectic). as long as there is slavery, there is no independence.
In drama, actors follow scripts. a kind of dependence. Hester plays her role, her part. But the fact that she is following a script of sorts indicates (a key word in Hawthorne!) that she is not acting (also key) independently. The spectators (the puritans) unthinkingly accept their part in matters, clinging (as obama would say) to scaffolds and religion (though without becoming bitter?).
The ideal in the scarlet letter is the Indian, free to roam, wild like nature is wild, like Pearl is wild. The Indian is outside of "the drama of grief and sorrow" told in the book.
What is the relationship between the scarlet letter's use of the rhetoric of theatricality and antebellum American theatre?
In continental writing on theatre in the 17th-early 19th centuries, the focus is on dramatic WRITING. the playwright is a POET, like the lyricist and epic-writer are poets. Plot and character are IT. Like Aristotle, spectacle/costume/music are not attended to. Until the twentieth century, really.
American theatre of the mid-19th-century was NOT like classical/high drama. It was not plot/character-based in the same way. Instead, American drama focused on SPECTACLE. People came not for the tragic plots or a mirror on life or a view of the human condition, but for STAR ACTORS who would strike POSES, and deliver moving SOLILOQUIES.
Hawthorne tapped into this American dramatic style (only now being taken seriously by scholars) through his use of the rhetoric of theatricality. Hawthorne is interested less in tragic plot than in the SPECTACLE of Puritan New England. Theatre is not just another kind of WRITING, as it was for continental theatre theoriests of the era, but a spectacular performance. Hawthorne was avant-avant garde.
Theatre offers Hawthorne a conceit through which to work through the DANGERS OF DEPENDENCE. American actors were able to both play roles (dependence!) AND make them their own (independence!) through personal acting styles. Hester Prynne toys with this independence, making her imposed COSTUME her own, but ultimately she can't break free. She cannot be self-reliant. Her life is summed up (on her tombstone, which she SHARES with Dimmesdale--they can't even have their own grave stones!) with a simple phrase, a description in words of her scarlet letter. She was nothing apart from her symbol. She was not able to escape into the woods, to run away to freedom.
Hers is the doom of antebellum America, a slave-economy, unable to free itself from that which defines it.
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Friday, July 10, 2009
A long and gloomy life
Good morning!
I don't particularly feel like writing this morning, but my window reading/writing chair makes it a pleasant task. I can watch people walking, and over the course of the day the shadows shift and make different patterns with the angles of the sidewalks.
In Nathaniel Hawthorne's notebooks, he'll be writing about a topic (politics, publishing, evil, etc) and suddenly he's telling us that Una (his daughter) "is bounding across the room with a light and graceful motion; but soon sinks down on the floor, complaining of being tired. Her mood to-day, is less tempestuous than usual--yet it has no settled level."
Gives his notebooks the feeling of immediacy. Not really of "being there," but of knowing that he was there, in the moment, sitting there with pen in hand with little Una playing ball with her brother. "She steps so boldly into the midst of everything." Love it. NH is obsessed with (and frightened by) his daughter. On the other hand, "The little boy is always the same child, and never varies in his relation to me."
The Norton Critical edition of SL only has a few pages from NH's notebooks; presumably the stuff pertinent to SL. Una no doubt is to be taken as inspiration for Pearl. Would like to read the entirety of his notebooks sometimes. Hunch is, Hawthorne is crazy. What's it like knowing your great (great?) grandfather beat a Quaker woman though the streets of Salem or that his son killed "witches"?
He's like a Faulkner character, struggling with his past, the violence of his ancestors. Wouldn't have been surprised if, after reading The Custom House, a friend had asked him, "Why do you hate Salem?" and he had responded, "I don't hate it! I don't hate it!"
Read a great essay on SL yesterday; by Stephen Railton, whose name (at least) I'd encountered before when I was (more) mad about reader-response criticism. This essay, "The Address of The Scarlet Letter," distinguishes between "readers" of a novel (or whatever) and its "audience." Anyone who picks up the book at any moment in time is a reader, but the audience is an imagined entity at whom the author directed his book. Imagined, but also real. Historically-specific, they precede the writing of the book, while the readers necessarily succeed it. Unless you are Sophia Hawthorne and reading drafts as the book is being written.
Railton argues that Hawthorne uses the Puritan spectators within the book to teach his 19thC audience to suspend judgment. The Puritans are "bad readers," unable to see ambiguity and quick to judge, slow to change. SR is a good writer, made for a pleasant essay. Would like to read his entire book.
SR was interested in the conventions of melodramatic sentimental fiction (uncle tom's cabin) and the expectations of the original audience. Their experience, he argued, was radically different from our own. For one thing, they wouldn't/couldn't have suspected Dimmsdale to be the father of Pearl, but we today supposedly always know this in advance. We feel immediately drawn to Hester, the Dark Heroine, while Hawthorne had to gradually win his audience's sympathy for her (through the discourse of motherhood, and the threat of separating mother from child).
I disagree that readers today always know in advance the father of Pearl (ha). The Scarlet Letter was my favorite book from the moment I read it sophomore year in high school until I read east of eden a few years later. And one of the reasons I loved it so much was my utter shock that Dimmsdale was the father. Perhaps I was naive. Perhaps I was closer to a Victorian American sentimentaliy than most. But it moved me.
As a once and future teacher, I fear that my students won't get to experience such shocks and pleasures of the text because they'll just read sparknotes or something. Which will give it all away and tell them what "themes, symbols, and motifs" are important.
Yesterday I also read NH's short story, "Young Goodman Brown," in which Brown goes to a nighttime celebration with the devil in the forest only to discover there all of the most upright citizens of his Puritan community. Then he wakes up (was it all a dream?) but he can't shake the suspicion that everything he knew was a lie, that everyone is a hypocrite. He lives a long and gloomy life. Of doubt.
I don't particularly feel like writing this morning, but my window reading/writing chair makes it a pleasant task. I can watch people walking, and over the course of the day the shadows shift and make different patterns with the angles of the sidewalks.
In Nathaniel Hawthorne's notebooks, he'll be writing about a topic (politics, publishing, evil, etc) and suddenly he's telling us that Una (his daughter) "is bounding across the room with a light and graceful motion; but soon sinks down on the floor, complaining of being tired. Her mood to-day, is less tempestuous than usual--yet it has no settled level."
Gives his notebooks the feeling of immediacy. Not really of "being there," but of knowing that he was there, in the moment, sitting there with pen in hand with little Una playing ball with her brother. "She steps so boldly into the midst of everything." Love it. NH is obsessed with (and frightened by) his daughter. On the other hand, "The little boy is always the same child, and never varies in his relation to me."
The Norton Critical edition of SL only has a few pages from NH's notebooks; presumably the stuff pertinent to SL. Una no doubt is to be taken as inspiration for Pearl. Would like to read the entirety of his notebooks sometimes. Hunch is, Hawthorne is crazy. What's it like knowing your great (great?) grandfather beat a Quaker woman though the streets of Salem or that his son killed "witches"?
He's like a Faulkner character, struggling with his past, the violence of his ancestors. Wouldn't have been surprised if, after reading The Custom House, a friend had asked him, "Why do you hate Salem?" and he had responded, "I don't hate it! I don't hate it!"
Read a great essay on SL yesterday; by Stephen Railton, whose name (at least) I'd encountered before when I was (more) mad about reader-response criticism. This essay, "The Address of The Scarlet Letter," distinguishes between "readers" of a novel (or whatever) and its "audience." Anyone who picks up the book at any moment in time is a reader, but the audience is an imagined entity at whom the author directed his book. Imagined, but also real. Historically-specific, they precede the writing of the book, while the readers necessarily succeed it. Unless you are Sophia Hawthorne and reading drafts as the book is being written.
Railton argues that Hawthorne uses the Puritan spectators within the book to teach his 19thC audience to suspend judgment. The Puritans are "bad readers," unable to see ambiguity and quick to judge, slow to change. SR is a good writer, made for a pleasant essay. Would like to read his entire book.
SR was interested in the conventions of melodramatic sentimental fiction (uncle tom's cabin) and the expectations of the original audience. Their experience, he argued, was radically different from our own. For one thing, they wouldn't/couldn't have suspected Dimmsdale to be the father of Pearl, but we today supposedly always know this in advance. We feel immediately drawn to Hester, the Dark Heroine, while Hawthorne had to gradually win his audience's sympathy for her (through the discourse of motherhood, and the threat of separating mother from child).
I disagree that readers today always know in advance the father of Pearl (ha). The Scarlet Letter was my favorite book from the moment I read it sophomore year in high school until I read east of eden a few years later. And one of the reasons I loved it so much was my utter shock that Dimmsdale was the father. Perhaps I was naive. Perhaps I was closer to a Victorian American sentimentaliy than most. But it moved me.
As a once and future teacher, I fear that my students won't get to experience such shocks and pleasures of the text because they'll just read sparknotes or something. Which will give it all away and tell them what "themes, symbols, and motifs" are important.
Yesterday I also read NH's short story, "Young Goodman Brown," in which Brown goes to a nighttime celebration with the devil in the forest only to discover there all of the most upright citizens of his Puritan community. Then he wakes up (was it all a dream?) but he can't shake the suspicion that everything he knew was a lie, that everyone is a hypocrite. He lives a long and gloomy life. Of doubt.
Thursday, July 9, 2009
An early start
I'm sitting in my reading chair, looking out over campus and listening to my "Pink Martini" playlist on Pandora. The plan for today includes my therapy appointment in center city, some reading at La Colombe, possibly a haircut.
I'm just at the start of the dissertation process, having submitted a sloppy draft of a proposal last week. The idea is to write in this blog every (work)day about my progress, to reflect on my process, and hopefully to figure out just what it is I'm doing.
My current thinking is that my dissertation will consider the use in mid-19th-century American literature of theatrical metaphors/language/imagery ("scenes," "masks," disguises," "playing roles," "playing one's part," "spectacle," "spectating"), particularly as this language has to do with race, freedom, slavery. For instance, if Hester Prynne mounts the scaffold "knowing well her part," how much free will is involved in her action? Is the choice wholly hers? Or is her behavior somehow "scripted"?
My plan of attack for now is to read the entirety of the Norton Critical Edition of The Scarlet Letter. Thus far I've read The Custom-House (from which I am taking the title of this blog), a couple critical essays on The C-H, excerpts from Hawthorne's notebooks and letters, and an essay by Sacvan Bercovitch on the (a)politics of ambiguity in SL.
Not sure what authors/texts will make it into the diss. Nor what my argument will be. I don't even know which (texts or argument) comes first. But in my proposal draft I mentioned everyone from David Walker and Edgar Allan Poe to James Weldon Johnson and Jean Toomer. The long 19th-Century.
Now to shower and walk to my therapy appointment. Looks to be a beautiful day.
Cheers.
I'm just at the start of the dissertation process, having submitted a sloppy draft of a proposal last week. The idea is to write in this blog every (work)day about my progress, to reflect on my process, and hopefully to figure out just what it is I'm doing.
My current thinking is that my dissertation will consider the use in mid-19th-century American literature of theatrical metaphors/language/imagery ("scenes," "masks," disguises," "playing roles," "playing one's part," "spectacle," "spectating"), particularly as this language has to do with race, freedom, slavery. For instance, if Hester Prynne mounts the scaffold "knowing well her part," how much free will is involved in her action? Is the choice wholly hers? Or is her behavior somehow "scripted"?
My plan of attack for now is to read the entirety of the Norton Critical Edition of The Scarlet Letter. Thus far I've read The Custom-House (from which I am taking the title of this blog), a couple critical essays on The C-H, excerpts from Hawthorne's notebooks and letters, and an essay by Sacvan Bercovitch on the (a)politics of ambiguity in SL.
Not sure what authors/texts will make it into the diss. Nor what my argument will be. I don't even know which (texts or argument) comes first. But in my proposal draft I mentioned everyone from David Walker and Edgar Allan Poe to James Weldon Johnson and Jean Toomer. The long 19th-Century.
Now to shower and walk to my therapy appointment. Looks to be a beautiful day.
Cheers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)